When it comes to books vs. movies, the book is (almost) always better. But the film adaptation of Where the Crawdads Sing is a near doppelganger of Delia Owens' masterpiece. I say this because when the music started to swell over the marsh, my personal waterworks sprung a leak.
Daisy Edgar-Jones (Normal People) stars as Kya Clark, the little girl-turned woman who raises herself in the wilds of North Carolina. Sensitive yet steely, she's exactly who I imagined, her refinement and reverence for nature defying the town's crude opinion of her. The rest of the cast is spot on too, with Taylor John Smith as the earnest Tate Walker and Harris Dickinson as arrogant Chase Andrews.
That said, the movie is less gritty and violent than the book. And although this detracts from the horror that helped shape Kya's worldview, it highlights the parts of the story that are charming yet enshrouded in mystery. In other words, it's Nicholas Sparks-meets-Agatha Christie -- in the most wonderful way. To make for a trifecta of icons, Taylor Swift's "Carolina" accompanies the credits, translating the haunting feel of Owens' unforgettable pages.
So if it's eerie enchantment you crave, then this is the flick for you. And if not, then no need to grouse about it.
There are plenty of other crawdads in the marsh.