Some people, it seems, disagreed with
my statement yesterday that "there is no possible universe in which
Green Arrow will
ever be as cool as
Hawkeye."
Well, not to stir a tempest in a teapot, but my statement was empirically, objectively, logically and certifiably true
.
VS.
Let's go to the science, shall we? [FYI, we're going with comic book incarnations here. Which actually levels the playing field a bit, as
MCU Hawkeye
blew up Loki with an exploding arrow]
ORIGIN:
Oliver Queen is the original 1%-er, a billionaire. Not a particularly good one, as he's lost and restored his fortune more times than
DC has announced and changed plans for a
Wonder Woman film. He became a hero because that's what billionaires did back then.
Hawkeye was an orphan who ran away and joined the circus.
Literally. And was taught to be a marksman
by a super-villain.
Easy win for Hawkeye.
COSTUME:
People like to make fun of Hawkeye's purple outfit.
And that's OK. Because the thing actually looks pretty good in the hands of a good artist:
And most people forget about
this one:
PHWOOOOAARRRRRR!!!
I'll take that over
ersatz Robin Hood any day.
OTHER POWERS:
Green Arrow fires arrows. And
more arrows.
Clint Barton, however, also was...
GOLIATH.
Another
clear decision for Hawkeye.
HOTTER GIRLFRIEND:
I'm not sure that this is a valid criteria, but let's play anyway.
Sure, Oliver has had, in some continuities, a long-term relationship with
Black Canary.
Of course, despite having a hot girlfriend, Green Arrow has had multiple (
multiple) infidelities, and a string of illegitimate children (apparently he never packed the
condom arrow). And
Dinah dumped him (more than once).
And I really think you're selling Hawkeye's
hot girlfriend/wife short:
And let's not forget--Clint Barton has probably the
ultimate tie-breaker:
So, yeah...
Black Widow AND Mockingbird. Pretty clear win for the Hawkster.
SIDEKICK:
I'm pretty sure that
this hasn't happened to
Kate Bishop yet:
Another win for
Hawkguy!
GREATEST TRIUMPHS:
Well, Hawkeye
once beat the Collector, all by himself, after all of the other
Avengers had been captured.
Oh, yeah, and
Hawkeye also
once beat the Grandmaster all by his lonesome, after all of the
East and West Coast Avengers were all killed (they got better).
Meanwhile, Green Arrow had a tough time
with this guy.
This is getting repetitive. A win for Hawkeye!!
LEADERSHIP:
Hawkeye was chairman and founder of the
West Coast Avengers.
Hawkeye was leader of the
Thunderbolts for quite awhile, getting super-villains to go straight, and turning them into effective heroes.
Green Arrow once led...well, he once...well, erm...as near as I can tell, Oliver Queen has
never been in charge of anything (except for failing businesses). He's more interested in reflexively arguing with whomever is in charge...
I think you know where this is going...
RANDOM POINTS:
They both died and came back. A toss-up, unless you want to give Ollie demerits for being revived by the
Hal Jordan Spectre.
Hawkeye went back in time to ye olde West, and fought
Kang with the
Two-Gun Kid.
Green Arrow had an
Arrow Cave and an
Arrow-Mobile and an
Arrow-Signal...and obviously the world's
biggest case of
Batman envy.
Green Arrow's beard, man...that chin hair...
Green Arrow has killed crooks. A lot. Big demerits in my book.
Well, none of that is enough to sway the final results: Hawkeye
1,000,000,000 and Green Arrow
0.
Sorry, Green Arrow fans--it's science!