Still haunted by his inability to
shave properly catch a
serial killer named The Doctor (strangely enough not Colin Baker, but Stephen
Rea doing a silly voice and a silly accent, probably because he wanted
something to do), despite the guy streaming his murders live on the
internet, police detective Mike (Stephen Dorff or the piece of wood they painted
to look like him) stumbles upon a series of very curious deaths. The victims
seem to die in accidents or by somewhat natural causes, but all of them see
terrible things before their deaths and bleed from the eyes. The last bit puts
health inspector – or something – Terry (Natascha McElhone or a different piece
of painted wood) on the case too, and she won’t stop helping Mike even though
it’s clear after five minutes of investigation that there’s no illness involved
in these deaths. The script will also very randomly drop a romance between Mike
and Terry on us, even though none of the scenes between them suggest any
emotional connection at all, let’s not even speak of chemistry. In fact, it
looks as if the actors were just as surprised by the development as the audience
is.
Anyway, some disconnected dialogue scenes that stand in for an investigation
later, our heroes learn that the victims are killed by a haunted website with
the rather awkward URL of “feardotcom.com”, an address that perfectly
encapsulates the quality of the writing here. Apparently, the site is haunted
(and designed?) by a ghost named Jeannine (sometimes Gesine Cukrowski in low
level bondage gear, sometimes Jana Güttgemans, a little girl wearing a
particularly obvious wig). Jeannine is a victim of the Doctor and uses her
powers of net haunting to curse random people coming to her site. The curse will
kill a victim after 48 hours of exposure via their greatest fear, unless,
apparently, they catch the Doctor. Why Jeannine thinks people like two
German-speaking punks who have nothing whatsoever to do with law enforcement
will be much help there, particularly since she doesn’t bother to actually tell
her victims what she wants from them, is anybody’s guess. I’m not particularly
hopeful the writers or director William Malone knew.
In fact, I have to hold myself back not to make a “you know nothing, Jon
Snow” joke here, for the writing as a whole is so inconsistent, implausible and
random in all the wrong ways, only utmost politeness can hold one back from
heaping personal abuse on the people responsible. Consequently, the plot outline
above is a best guess effort.
At the time it came out,
Feardotcom was positioned as an attempt of
getting at some of that sweet money reserved for bad US remakes of markedly
superior Japanese horror films without actually having to buy any rights (or,
one might add, perhaps with a degree of unkindness, without actually having a
script). In practice, there certainly are some plot parallels to Nakata’s
Ringu or Kiyoshi Kurosawa’s
Kairo but there’s exactly zero of
the complexity or aesthetic achievement of these films visible on screen. In
fact, the film seems more in the spirit of Italian rip-off cinema of the 70s –
with the little difference that where Italian rip-offs of successful movies were
often highly entertaining,
Feardotcom is mostly boring.
Much of that boredom is what happens when a cast of characters consisting of
non-entities mostly lacking the single character trait even a slasher movie
victim gets wander through thematically indifferent set-pieces which in turn
meander between vapid and unexciting horror sequences shot in very dark rooms,
third-rate would-be
Seven-style serial killer non-thriller scenes shot
in very dark rooms, and flash cuts too embarrassing even for a White Zombie or
Marilyn Manson video clip.
I could probably live with the total lack of thematic coherence, the film’s
disinterest in its own narrative, and the non-characters if the visual aspects
of the film suggested anything beyond Malone having seen some music videos, and
a David Fincher film and probably once having heard of Japan and Italy
and now crapping it all back on screen without rhyme, reason, a concept, or even
an idea of mood. The courageous handful of defenders of
Feardotcom (and
all power to defenders of hopeless causes like this) tend to argue the film is
actually a rather stylish affair but to my eyes and ears, there’s no coherence
to its style, and therefore no style at all.